CRITICAL APPRAISAL



 Utility of CBNAAT, Cytology and Histology in diagnosis of suspected tubercular solid lymph node


Aims and Objectives: 

To asses efficacy of various diagnostic tools for diagnosis of lymph node tuberculosis in solid state (non-caseating stage).


Methods : 

Prospective observational study over a period of 18 months


Inclusion criteria : 

Clinically suspected extra Pulmonary TB

Suspected LNTB patients on ATT


Exclusion criteria : 

HIV positive patients

Fluctuant node 

on ATT

Patients with cheesy / pus on aspiration of node.


Patients : 

82 patients were initially selected out of which 22 patients were excluded from the study as they are under exclusion criteria.

Out of 60 patients 31 ( 51.67%) were tested positive for MTB in CBNAAT of which 2 are Rifampcin Resistant and remaining 29 patients were opted for excisional biopsy. 

Remaining patients after histology had following diagnosis; Tuberculosis in eight, nonspecific reactive hyperplasia in 11, metastasis and lymphoma in four and Non Tubercular Mycobacteria and actinomycosis in one each patient.


9 out of 60 ( 15%) were detected AFB on ZN stain of which all are CBNAAT positive for MTB.


CBNAAT could not diagnose (8/39) 20% of patients with tuberculosis which are diagnosed by histopathology.


CBNAAT diagnosed 22 (70%) cases which were missed by AFB smear & 16 cases missed by cytology.


Cytological findings of tuberculosis -granulomatous inflammation with or without necrosis was looked for and found in 21/60 patients

A peculiar pattern of reactive hyperplasia was found in 26/60 out of which 15 found positive for MTb on Cbnaat or histology.


Cytological finding correlated with final diagnosis (including Tuberculosis and other diagnoses) in 56.67 % (34/60) cases and final diagnosis was different from cytology in 43.33 % (26/60) cases.





Conclusion : 


CBNAAT has 79% sensitivity ( ruling out a disease ) and 100% specificity ( ruling in a disease) in diagnosing Lymphnode Tuberculosis even in adinitis and non caseous stage although yeild is less compared to caseous stage.


https://www.ijirm.org/html-article/12187

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bi Monthly Exam May 2021

Image
Below is the link of the questions asked regarding the cases: http://medicinedepartment.blogspot.com/2021/05/online-blended-bimonthly-assignment.html?m=1 1)Pulmonology  A) Link to patient details: https://soumyanadella128eloggm.blogspot.com/2021/05/a-55-year-old-female-with-shortness-of.html . Questions 1:  What is the evolution of the symptomatology in this patient in terms of an event timeline and where is the anatomical localization for the problem and what is the primary etiology of the patient's problem? Answer:  The following is the event timeline of symptom occurrences in the patient:  1st episode of SOB 20 years ago was of Grade 2. Lasted one week. Relieved on medication  Next 8 years, similar events every January which lasted 1 week, grade 2 severity. Relieved on medication  Was diagnosed with Diabetes 18 years ago  2nd severe episode of SOB 12 years ago and was of grade 2 type. Lasted 20 days. Relieved on hospitalization and treatment Next 12...
Read more

Bi monthly exam Dec 16

Image
  This is my submission for the Bimonthly internal assessment for the month of November." Most of the information here have been collected from different reference sites, the links to which have been mentioned. The points copy pasted have been put in quotes.  The questions to the cases being discussed can be viewed from the link below 👇 https://medicinedepartment.blogspot.com/2020/12/medicine-question-paper-for-december.html?m=1 1) A 55 year old man with Recurrent Focal Seizures Detailed patient case report here:  http://ushaindurthi. blogspot.com/2020/11/55-year- old-male-with-complaints-of. html 1. What is the problem representation of this patient and what could be the anatomical site of lesion ? Ans :  55 year old man presented to the casualty with the complaints of Unable to move his right upper limb he suddenly started complaining that he couldn’t move his right upper limb few minutes later he developed a sudden onset, tonic clonic seizures involving his right...
Read more
 57 year old man with a long term alcohol consumption with the symptoms of yellowish discoloration of eyes, abdominal distention, bleeding manifestations along with hypoalbuminaemia, asterixis, constructional apraxia gives a picture of acute decompensation liver failure. In liver failure with  portal hypertension, the patient develops fluid and salt retention because of splanchnic vasodilation which leads to activation of sympathetic system activity, renin angiotensin aldosterone system activation leading to fluid and salt retention which lead to his ascites 2. With long standing fluid and salt retention which lead to his bilateral pedal edema would've lead to venous obstruction and lymphatic obstruction explaining his lymph edema. Venous stasis and lymphedema for a prolonged duration would've left to cellulitis along with recurrent blebs and ulcers, prone to recurrent infections 3. Asterexis and constructional apraxia are signs of hepatic encephalopathy due to accumulation of...
Read more